Studio: Neon
Director: Damian McCarthy
Writer: Damian McCarthy
Producer: Roy Lee, Steven Schneider, Derek Dauchy, Ruth Treacy, Julianna Forde, Mairtin de Barra
Stars: Adam Scott, Peter Coonan, David Wilmot, Florence Ordesh, Michael Patric, Will O’Connell, Brendan Conroy, Ezra Carlisle, Austin Amelio
Review Score:
Summary:
An author becomes embroiled in a murder mystery and confronts a dark family secret while visiting a secluded Irish hotel rumored to be haunted by a witch.
Review:
Aided by spot-on casting to complement their clean and clear characterizations, “Hokum” sets up the eclectic lot populating Ireland’s secluded Bilberry Woods Hotel quickly. No-nonsense groundskeeper Fergal doesn’t hesitate to fire his crossbow into a troublesome goat plaguing the premises. Meek beanpole Alby toils as a dutiful bellhop, yet he privately yearns to become a writer. Inside the hotel, desk clerk Mal fears his formidable father-in-law Mr. Cob, the property’s eccentric owner who is pleased as punch to terrify two boys with tales of a witch supposedly locked in the honeymoon suite. Kindly bartender Fiona, whose easygoing personality can soften hard hearts, believes more than a few of those folktales. So does bearded weirdo Jerry, a local loon who lives alone in a nearby forest where he farms his own magic mushrooms.
But the movie’s main player is Ohm Bauman, a caustic author played by Adam Scott. Don’t expect to see the actor on his best behavior. Ohm is far from the quirky, comical types Scott plays in projects like “Parks and Recreation,” or even the affable Everyman he embodies on “Severance.” Constantly condescending, Ohm challenges Fergal’s goat slaughter as an unnecessary action, interrupts Mr. Cob’s storytelling to warn the boys they shouldn’t talk to strangers, and adds injury to insult by intentionally burning Alby’s hand for being momentarily inconvenienced by the bellhop’s flattering banter.
Despite him responding with a sarcastic “what does it look like?” when she asks if he’s lost, Fiona helps Ohm pinpoint a particular tree in the forest and he starts easing up his confrontational attitude. The reason Ohm came to Ireland in the first place is because he recently finished his highly anticipated new novel, albeit with a bleak ending, and a quick flash of his mother’s ghost inspired him to scatter his parents’ ashes at the place where they spent their honeymoon.
Since “Hokum” is a horror movie, this is only the beginning of Ohm’s bizarre experience at the Bilberry Woods Hotel. After a shocking incident lands him in the hospital, Ohm returns to the hotel to learn an employee went missing. They aren’t the first person to meet a mysterious fate either. The only place that hasn’t been searched is the honeymoon suite, because it’s been permanently shuttered since Mr. Cob purportedly trapped the witch in there. Ohm decides to do some digging on his own. What he ends up discovering is one secret someone desperately wants to remain hidden, and another that will force Ohm to face a tragic truth about his family, if he can survive the witch’s wrath along the way.
Having previously paved this path with 2020’s “Caveat” (review here) and then “Oddity” in 2024 (review here), Damian McCarthy’s third feature “Hokum” shows the filmmaker fine-tuning his personal formula for disturbing descents into darkness even further. His keen sense for combining urban legend lore and a woodland countryside setting with grim themes about guilt and modern movie flourishes makes for carefully crafted folk horror that manages the feat of feeling both classic and contemporary at the same time.
That texture develops out of “Hokum’s” ability to balance between two similar yet distinct tones depending on how a given scene wants to stir up a scare. The throughline always ties back to the myth of the witch and how she seems to be a part of evil events within the hotel’s walls, but there are also the other plots involving Ohm’s haunted history and the possible murder conspiracy going on in the meantime. By not relying solely on psychological dread over physical frights or vice versa, the film’s slow burn has free reign to plume the smoking suspense of cerebral dread from suggestive images and audio while more tangible terrors develop out of direct dangers and threats. Some of those moments aren’t all the way on the James Wan scale of being spectacularly stylized, but they aren’t cheap jumps either.
Although “Hokum” maintains a much faster pace than “Caveat” and “Oddity,” viewers who weren’t synched to the speed of those films may find themselves similarly halted here. Admirers of those movies, on the other hand, have an opposite experience in store as Damian McCarthy takes the lessons learned on those outings to dial up “Hokum’s” horror even higher. Covered in a macabre mood, “Hokum” has more than mere atmosphere to offer as it evolves into a self-contained creeper that’s quickly cementing McCarthy as a master of effective, artistic, and unsettling eeriness.
Review Score: 75
Damian McCarthy’s third feature “Hokum” shows the filmmaker fine-tuning his personal formula for disturbing descents into darkness even further.