Studio: Neon
Director: Tilman Singer
Writer: Tilman Singer
Producer: Markus Halberschmidt, Josh Rosenbaum, Maria Tsigka, Ken Kao, Thor Bradwell, Ben Rimmer
Stars: Hunter Schafer, Jan Bluthardt, Marton Csokas, Jessica Henwick, Dan Stevens, Mila Lieu, Greta Fernandez, Proschat Madani
Review Score:
Summary:
When her family relocates to a remote resort in Germany, a troubled teenager becomes unwittingly involved in a mysterious man's unusual experiments.
Review:
You wouldn't know it from the premise, or from its outward appearance as a slightly surreal psycho-thriller, but "Cuckoo" is a coming-of-age story set inside a fright film. It's not nostalgic or sentimental like "Stand by Me." It's not even off-kilter like "Lisa Frankenstein" (review here). "Cuckoo" is weirder than that. Imagine the hypnotic horror of Panos Cosmatos meets David Lynch dreaminess with an arty A24 style whirled together in a macabre midnight movie, yet still approachable for mainstream audiences who want to walk on the wilder side for 100 minutes. "Cuckoo" is that kind of weird.
17-year-old Gretchen misses her recently deceased mother. She misses her even more now that she's stuck in the Bavarian Alps with her father Luis, stepmother Beth, and mute half-sister Alma. The family traded America for Germany so Beth and Luis can help Herr Konig build a new resort to replace the one he currently owns on a campus with a research hospital. Gretchen even gets in on the business, accepting an offer to become a front desk receptionist who rents out the hotel's rooms.
Between the awkward doctor from that nearby hospital to the hotel guest who repeatedly vomits in the lobby, Resort Alpschatten has no shortage of unusual denizens. Oddness soon escalates into unsettling circumstances whenever shrieking emanates from the surrounding forest, causing everything from trance-like convulsions for Alma to time suddenly skipping and inexplicably restarting for Gretchen. Confused unease then becomes outright terror when a hooded woman emerges from the darkness to frantically chase down Gretchen before disappearing just as mysteriously as she materialized.
What could possibly be going on here? Pull every prediction you can from previous suspense films set at remote resorts or isolated clinics. Are anomalies part of an imagined fantasy a la "Shutter Island?" Is a mad scientist conducting clandestine experiments as in "A Cure for Wellness" (review here)? Maybe it's a bit of both and then some? Wonder all you want, then throw your guess in the garbage, because the details driving "Cuckoo's" strange sights and stranger sounds are too out of the ordinary to see coming. You can certainly see how particular people and pieces fit into a puzzle, but the full reveal concocts a concept that's creatively creepy enough to earn admiration from a diabolical comic book villain, and I mean that as a compliment.
The movie doesn't work toward a Shyamalan-style bombshell or mind-blowingly bonkers twist. Rather, "Cuckoo" warps itself sideways by leaning into B-movie bizarreness befitting the lightly hallucinatory texture and mind-going-mad tone. "Cuckoo" piles on sinister suggestiveness with a vaguely "Silent Hill"-like soundtrack, too. Not with the heart-pounding noisiness of Pyramid Head chasing a hero through a hospital's blood-caked hallways, but with the echoing eeriness of exploring the cursed town in quieter moments.
Amid occasionally dizzying weirdness, "Cuckoo" stays centered thanks to the remarkable writing, directing, and acting that goes into establishing Gretchen as the grounding element. I say remarkable because the troubled teen stereotype is so easy to turn into a trope, and so easy for audiences to find obnoxious, it's incredible for "Cuckoo" to create a take where her rebellious angst is relatable instead of annoying.
In presenting attitudinal teens, movies often open with them blatantly disrespecting others while insolently huffing and puffing. Gretchen doesn't care for her stepmother or her half-sister, but she ignores them in a manner where she mostly avoids them rather than hurl undeserved insults to make her the center of attention. Also, instead of moping, Gretchen mourns her mother's passing in emotionally devastating moments where actor Hunter Schafer's heartbroken tears easily earn sympathy. Even Gretchen's habit of shutting out the rest of the world via headphones ends up being a plot point when it could have been one more example of her echoing every other onscreen teen with an unearned ax to grind.
What makes or breaks the movie for any individual comes down to whether the narrative earns a satisfied smirk or an exasperated groan. Until the fiction completely emerges from a fog with the last wisps of third act exposition, "Cuckoo" can be maddening for anyone anxious to get every finger gripped around exactly what is happening and why. While most questions are answered, some aren't, likely leaving more than a few viewers flustered. Honestly, I wasn't even sure I fully followed along until I put my notes together for a detailed synopsis and saw that everything did, mostly, make sense in retrospect, even if it didn't in the moment.
To someone concerned about "Cuckoo's" cryptic nature, I'd insist it's not a movie for half-watching while crushing candies or scrolling social media. In addition to intermittent insertions of subtitled languages, "Cuckoo" has a hint of exotic flavors that make it an experience worth an immersion, and investment, of imagination. Remember, it's a weird one, which by definition means it's definitely not tailored to everyone's tastes.
Review Score: 65
At least the movie only runs 70 minutes, though I suppose that extra 10 technically disqualifies it from being a literal amateur hour.